Plastisol
The most common technique on 90s band tees. The ink sits on top of the fabric like a skin, with strong colour. After years of wear and washing it develops fine, irregular cracks.
What to look for: old plastisol cracks gradually, so the depth and density of the cracks vary across the design. Cracking that is too even, like a grid, deserves a second look.
Water-based
The ink soaks into the fibres, so the print feels soft and you can barely feel it. More common on light shirts. It ages by fading overall rather than cracking.
Discharge
The dye in a dark fabric is removed and replaced with colour, so the print becomes part of the fabric and feels almost like no print at all. Many soft prints on dark shirts are discharge.
Puff print
The ink rises when heated, giving a raised, 3D feel. Many 80s and 90s shirts used puff for lettering. Old puff prints are often flattened, hardened or partly peeling.
Digital (DTG)
Direct-to-garment printing only became widespread in the last decade or so. It works like an inkjet printer on fabric. Under magnification you often see fine grain, and the edges are less sharp than a screen print. If a shirt claimed to be from the 90s has a DTG print, it is almost certainly a reproduction.
Practical method: use your phone's macro mode or a loupe on the edges and halftone dots. Screen-printed dots are regular with clean edges; DTG grain is finer and more random.