First, two kinds of “bootleg”
One is the period bootleg: unofficial shirts sold outside shows or at markets in the 90s. Thailand produced plenty of them. They are vintage in their own right and have their own collectors.
The other is the modern reproduction: made in recent years and styled to look old. When we say “fake”, we mainly mean the second passed off as the first.
Giveaway 1: print and shirt don't age together
An old screen print that has been worn and washed for years cracks and fades naturally, in step with the shirt itself. A brand-new print on a worn shirt, or an evenly cracked print on a fresh shirt, is a warning sign. Digital (DTG) prints often show fine dots under magnification and feel different from old screen prints.
Giveaway 2: clues that contradict each other
The copyright date, tag, stitching and country of origin don't match, for example a ©1991 print on a tag style that only became common after 2000. Remember that the copyright date only shows when the design first appeared; reproductions copy it too.
Giveaway 3: a suspicious tag
Blurry lettering, the wrong colours, thread that doesn't match the rest of the shirt, or a tag that has clearly been sewn in later.
Giveaway 4: distressing that looks staged
Artificial holes and fading often sit in unnatural places, such as wear where a shirt never rubs, or damage that looks too neat.
When in doubt, call it “inconclusive” rather than forcing an answer. If you can't decide, send us the photos.